The Science Behind EMDR
The Science Behind EMDR:
Why Eye Movements Can Unlock Trapped Trauma
Delve into the fascinating mechanisms of Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) therapy. Understand how this powerful approach helps your brain process and heal from distressing memories, paving the way for lasting recovery.
EMDR: A Quick Overview
Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) therapy is a structured psychotherapy primarily developed by Dr. Francine Shapiro to treat trauma and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). However, its applications have expanded to address a wide range of psychological distress, including anxiety, depression, phobias, and grief.
At its core, EMDR therapy facilitates the accessing and processing of traumatic memories to bring them to an adaptive resolution. This means that while the memory of a difficult event remains, the distressing emotional charge and negative beliefs associated with it are significantly reduced. Clients often report that the memory becomes less vivid, less intrusive, and feels more like a distant part of their past rather than a current, overwhelming threat.
Key Components of EMDR
- Standardized Eight-Phase Protocol: Ensures a structured and safe approach.
- Bilateral Stimulation (BLS): Typically eye movements, but can also be auditory tones or tactile tapping.
- Focus on Memory Networks: Targets specific distressing memories and associated beliefs, emotions, and sensations.
- Goal of Adaptive Resolution: Aims to integrate traumatic memories into a broader, healthier perspective.
But how does it actually work? What is the science that makes following a therapist’s fingers with your eyes, or attending to other forms of bilateral stimulation, so effective in healing deep-seated trauma? Let’s explore the leading theories.
The Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) Model
The foundational theory underpinning EMDR is Dr. Francine Shapiro’s Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) model. This model posits that the human brain has an inherent, natural system for processing information and experiences, moving them towards an adaptive resolution. Think of it like your body’s immune system, but for psychological experiences.
Normally, when you experience an event, your brain processes the sights, sounds, thoughts, and feelings, and integrates this information into your existing memory networks. This allows you to learn from the experience and move forward.
The AIP model suggests that traumatic experiences can overwhelm this natural processing system. The memory of the trauma, along with its associated images, sounds, emotions, physical sensations, and beliefs, gets inadequately processed and “stuck” in the brain in its original, raw, disturbing form.
These unprocessed memories are stored in isolated neural networks, disconnected from more adaptive information. When triggered, they can replay with the same intensity as the original event, leading to symptoms of PTSD, anxiety, and other issues. It’s like a file on your computer that’s become corrupted and keeps crashing the system.
How EMDR Relates to AIP
EMDR, particularly through bilateral stimulation, is believed to “unstick” these memories. It stimulates the brain’s information processing system, allowing it to link the traumatic memory with more adaptive information already stored in other memory networks. This allows the brain to:
- Desensitize: Reduce the emotional distress associated with the memory.
- Reprocess: Change the negative beliefs associated with the memory to more positive, adaptive ones.
- Integrate: Store the memory in a way that it is no longer disruptive, becoming just a part of one’s history.
Essentially, EMDR helps the brain do what it naturally does, but for experiences that were too overwhelming to process at the time.
The Role of Bilateral Stimulation (BLS)
Bilateral stimulation is a core component of EMDR and refers to the alternating, rhythmic, left-right stimulation of the brain. While eye movements are the most well-known form, BLS can also involve:
- Auditory BLS: Listening to tones alternating between the left and right ears via headphones.
- Tactile BLS: Holding small pulsers that vibrate alternately in each hand, or gentle tapping on alternate hands or knees.
The exact mechanisms by which BLS facilitates trauma processing are still being researched, but several compelling theories exist. It’s likely a combination of factors rather than a single explanation.
Working Memory Theory & EMDR
One prominent theory suggests that BLS works by taxing working memory. Working memory is the brain system responsible for temporarily holding and manipulating information for complex cognitive tasks like learning, reasoning, and comprehension. It has limited capacity.
The Dual-Attention Task
During EMDR, clients are asked to simultaneously focus on two things:
1. The distressing traumatic memory.
2. The external bilateral stimulation (e.g., eye movements).
This “dual-attention” task creates competition for limited working memory resources.
Impact on Memory Vividness & Emotion
The theory proposes that because working memory is engaged by the BLS, fewer resources are available to hold the traumatic memory in its full vividness and emotional intensity. As a result:
- The vividness of the memory decreases.
- The emotional charge of the memory lessens.
This makes the memory less overwhelming and easier for the brain to process and integrate into adaptive memory networks. It’s like trying to hold a detailed image in your mind while also solving a math problem – the image might become fuzzier.
Repeated sets of BLS while focusing on the memory may progressively reduce its intensity and allow for reconsolidation in a less distressing form.
Parallels with REM Sleep Processing
Another intriguing line of thought draws parallels between the eye movements in EMDR and those that occur naturally during Rapid Eye Movement (REM) sleep. REM sleep is a stage of sleep known to be crucial for memory consolidation and emotional processing.
During REM sleep, our eyes move rapidly back and forth. It’s hypothesized that these eye movements, similar to those in EMDR, play a role in:
- Processing emotional experiences from the day.
- Integrating new information with existing memories.
- Reducing the emotional intensity of past events.
Mimicking Natural Processes?
Some researchers suggest that the bilateral stimulation in EMDR might mimic or activate similar neurobiological processes that occur during REM sleep. By engaging these processes while awake and focused on a traumatic memory, EMDR could be kick-starting the brain’s natural adaptive processing mechanisms that were disrupted by the trauma.
This could explain why EMDR can feel like a very deep and sometimes rapid form of processing, similar to how we often feel a sense of resolution about certain issues after a good night’s sleep.
While the REM sleep analogy is compelling, it’s important to note that EMDR works with various forms of BLS, not just eye movements. This suggests that while REM-like processes might be involved, other mechanisms are also at play.
Neurobiological Changes Observed with EMDR
Neuroimaging studies (like fMRI and EEG) have started to shed light on the brain changes associated with EMDR therapy. While research is ongoing, findings suggest that EMDR can lead to tangible shifts in brain activity and connectivity:
Studies have shown decreased activity in areas like the amygdala (the brain’s fear center) in response to traumatic memories after successful EMDR. This correlates with clients reporting less emotional distress.
The prefrontal cortex, involved in higher-level thinking, emotional regulation, and impulse control, often shows increased activity. This suggests better cognitive control over traumatic memories and emotional responses.
The hippocampus plays a key role in memory formation and contextualizing experiences. Trauma can impair its function. EMDR may help restore more normal hippocampal activity, allowing memories to be placed in proper context (i.e., in the past).
Some studies indicate increased coherence (synchronized activity) between different brain regions after EMDR, suggesting better communication and integration of information related to the trauma.
These neurobiological findings support the idea that EMDR helps the brain re-organize how traumatic memories are stored and processed, shifting from a state of hyperarousal and fragmentation to one of calm integration and adaptive understanding.
Memory Reconsolidation and EMDR
The concept of memory reconsolidation offers another powerful lens through which to understand EMDR’s effectiveness. This theory suggests that when a consolidated (long-term) memory is retrieved, it enters a temporary, labile (unstable) state. During this brief window, the memory can be modified before it is re-stabilized or “reconsolidated.”
Updating Old Files
In EMDR, the client intentionally brings up the traumatic memory (retrieval). The introduction of bilateral stimulation during this labile period might disrupt the original emotional and cognitive patterns associated with the memory. This creates an opportunity to integrate new, more adaptive information (like safety in the present, or a positive self-belief) before the memory is “saved” again.
Essentially, EMDR could be helping to “update the old file” of the traumatic memory with new information, reducing its negative charge and changing its meaning. This is not about erasing the memory, but changing its impact and how it’s stored.
This aligns with the AIP model’s idea of linking isolated traumatic memories with broader, more adaptive neural networks.
Why Understanding the Science Matters
For individuals considering EMDR therapy, understanding the science behind it can be empowering:
- Demystifies the Process: Knowing that EMDR is based on established neurological and psychological principles can reduce apprehension and make the therapy feel less mysterious.
- Builds Trust and Hope: Understanding that EMDR leverages the brain’s natural healing capacities can instill confidence in the process and hope for recovery.
- Validates Experiences: Learning how trauma affects the brain can help individuals understand why they’ve been struggling, reducing self-blame.
- Encourages Engagement: When clients understand the rationale, they may be more engaged and committed to the therapeutic process.
At Kaplan Therapy, we believe in psychoeducation. We want our clients to feel informed and be active partners in their healing journey. Understanding the science is part of that empowerment.
The EMDR Process: A Scientific Journey in 8 Phases
EMDR therapy is not just about eye movements; it’s a comprehensive, eight-phase approach that systematically addresses traumatic memories. Each phase has a specific scientific rationale:
Scientific Rationale: Assess client readiness, identify specific memories for processing (targets), and develop a safe treatment plan. Ensures stability and identifies potential blocks to processing. Based on understanding memory networks and client’s overall psychological state.
Scientific Rationale: Equip client with coping skills (e.g., “safe place” visualization, grounding techniques) to manage emotional distress. Explains the EMDR process, builds therapeutic alliance. Activates self-soothing neural pathways and ensures client feels in control.
Scientific Rationale: Activate the specific memory network to be processed. Identify key components: image, negative cognition (NC), positive cognition (PC), emotions, Subjective Units of Disturbance (SUDs), and body sensations. This primes the memory for reprocessing.
Scientific Rationale: This is where BLS is introduced while focusing on the target memory. Aims to reduce the SUDs level by taxing working memory, activating AIP, and potentially mimicking REM-like processing, allowing the distress to diminish.
Scientific Rationale: Strengthen the preferred PC by pairing it with the original memory (now less distressing) during BLS. Reinforces new, adaptive neural pathways and beliefs. Leverages memory reconsolidation principles.
Scientific Rationale: Address any residual physical tension or discomfort associated with the memory. Somatic (body-based) processing is crucial as trauma is often held in the body. Ensures complete processing.
Scientific Rationale: Ensure client feels stable and calm at session end, whether processing is complete or not. Reinforce self-care and grounding. Manages expectations for inter-session processing based on understanding that neural changes can continue.
Scientific Rationale: At the start of the next session, check for maintained treatment effects, new insights, or related memories that may have emerged. Confirms adaptive resolution and guides future treatment targets. Validates long-term changes in memory networks.
EMDR at Kaplan Therapy: Your Path to Healing
At Kaplan Therapy, our certified EMDR therapists are dedicated to providing this evidence-based treatment with compassion and expertise. We understand that trauma is a deeply personal experience, and we tailor our approach to your unique needs within the structured EMDR framework.
If you’re struggling with the weight of past experiences and wondering if EMDR can help, we invite you to reach out. We can discuss your situation, answer your questions about the science and process of EMDR, and explore how it might unlock your innate capacity for healing.
Schedule a ConsultationDiscover more from Kaplan Therapy
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.